[Flash] Ditch Opinionated. Become a Thought Partner. – MentorLead | The #1 Healthcare Mentorship Solution

[Flash] Ditch Opinionated. Become a Thought Partner.

Over my 25 years of running businesses, I’ve paid numerous consultants to give me their advice (secretly hoping they would absolve me of the responsibility of making a decision!). Too often, I ended up ignoring their advice, grumbling that they didn’t understand my situation.

The irony of asking for advice about an important decision is that we don’t necessarily want someone telling us what to do. Research shows that advice-seeking decision makers are actually seeking validation, perspective, and sense-making support.

When people ask for our advice, we tend to lead with our opinion, which is typically informed by our experiences, not theirs. It often sounds like “You know what you should do…” 

In sharing our opinion-cloaked advice, we risk robbing people of the ownership of their decision.

What to do? Contribute differently. Become a Thought Partner. Help people think and make sense of their choices by posing probing questions:

  • What would it be like for you if you…?
  • How do you feel about…?
  • Are you willing to…?
  • Are you ready to…?
  • What if you do nothing? 
  • What might you regret?
  • What alternative options have you considered?
  • How will you measure success?
  • What’s the worst that can happen?
  • What’s the best that can happen?

For example, if your Mentee asks for your advice on her lingering decision to change jobs to end her strenuous relationship with her boss, fight the urge to impose your opinion.

Instead, be her Thought Partner – help her think through the decision.

Thought Partners don’t have an agenda. Ultimately, it doesn’t matter what decision your Mentee makes – it only matters that she feels supported as she gallops and grows.

You might ask:

  • What would it take to improve the experience with your boss?
  • How will you feel about your position if the situation with your boss doesn’t change?
  • How could you leverage this challenging situation?
  • Which role will help you best develop and grow your career?
  • Are there other options besides these two?
  • Is there any urgency to this decision?
  • Are you prepared if your next boss is similarly difficult? 

After twisting the kaleidoscope a few times, you could share your own insights and wisdom“When I was in a similar situation, I found it helpful to…” “The best advice I ever received was…”

When Mentors help people think and grow, they become valuable Thought Partners.

© 2026. Ann Tardy and MentorLead. www.mentorlead.com. All Rights Reserved.

About the Author